• Premium
  • About
  • Partner Pages
  • Support & FAQs
  • Log in

The Mandarin

The Mandarin
The Mandarin
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors’ Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library
  • Small Logo
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors’ Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library

Promoted

Home Sponsored Post-Royal Commission, are we measuring, auditing, or evaluating culture?

Post-Royal Commission, are we measuring, auditing, or evaluating culture?

By Synergy Group

May 7, 2019

In the turbulence following the release of the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry’s final report, measuring culture has surfaced as a possible life raft for senior leaders. Unfortunately, it is proving, as it always has done, to be a slippery concept.

The Royal Commission was clear on the importance of culture: “Failings of organisational culture, governance arrangements and remuneration systems lie at the heart of much of the misconduct examined in this Commission.”

It was also clear on the shape of the solution, “Culture, governance and remuneration march together. Improvements in one area will reinforce improvements in others, inaction in one area will undermine progress in others.” The challenge is what to do next.

The lingering problem of measuring culture

Following the Royal Commission, culture has been in the spotlight with many experts all expressing their views on the subject. There has also been a new wave of ‘measurement experts’ unveiling the solution to measuring culture.

Synergy Audit Partner Phil Toole says we should be careful about rushing to a solution. Toole likes a line from the book Think Like a Freak. “The fact is that solving problems is hard. If a given problem still exists, you can bet that a lot of people have already come along and failed to solve it. Easy problems evaporate; it is the hard ones that linger.”

“Measuring culture is a problem that has been lingering for some time,” says Toole. “Are we measuring, auditing or evaluating culture? Knowing where we are starting is important to where we are going to finish,” he asks.

He says the post-Royal Commission commentary on culture has focused on measurement which seems to a narrow perspective and is not linked to an outcome. “Similarly, the Royal Commission focused heavily on the link between remuneration systems, culture and behaviour. I think this also limits our view on culture,” says Toole.

Toole says when he is working with government audit clients the question is, how do I assure the Secretary and senior management that the control and governance framework that is in place reduces the risk of failings identified in the Royal Commission?

“This is a different question from measurement. It is very practical and immediate. It is focused on the realities of providing assurance on the operation of controls and governance processes. Other clients are asking my colleagues working on workforce issues about measuring the effectiveness of strategies to shape culture. These are evaluation questions. They are closely related questions, but they are not the same. For me, clearly understanding the connections culture creates across our organisations. We need to be clear so that we measure, audit or evaluate the right things. Rushing to implement an audit, governance or workforce solution in isolation will not serve us well,” says Toole.

One of the lessons of the Royal Commission is that senior leaders have a rosy view of their organisation’s culture. The annual State of the Service report has made similar observations about the Australian Public Service (APS). The Senior Executive Services is often more positive than other APS employees. “While we have a lot of information on some aspects of organisational culture through employee surveys, however this information is not aligned with the audit standards regarding audit evidence, it also doesn’t fully help us to get an early indication of the failings identified by the Royal Commission,” says Toole.

Sally Dorsett and David Schmidtchen from Synergy’s People and Organisational Development practice are working closely with Toole to develop a more comprehensive and sensitive approach to auditing and evaluating organisational culture in government agencies and departments.

“Business units and small teams have a culture that can be at odds with the institutional culture. Culture forms around accepted behaviours and ways of working that are developed over time. New members of the team are then brought that way of working as the acceptable norm. To measure culture, we need to get underneath the obvious and easily observed at the local level,” says Dorsett.  “We also need to get beyond the simplistic notions that culture is this or it is not that. We are not really measuring culture at all. We are focused on behaviour that is consistent with achieving an outcome,” says Schmidtchen.

“We have developed and are continuing to refine a more complete approach by focusing on the way culture, governance, and audit can work together. But we need to anchor our approach on achieving organisational outcomes. We need to make sure the statements we make in our corporate plans about workforce, the way we work, and how that contributes to collective performance are more than, as Commissioner Hayne put it when referring to industry codes, ‘public relations puff’.

These provide the foundation for developing behavioural statements that we can measure, audit and evaluate. Without this, there will be a lot of measurement but nothing that helps us to identify whether we are at risk or whether our strategies are working. We will have no basis for improving,” says Toole.

If senior leaders should take one lesson from the findings of the Royal Commission, it is that there is no easy answer, quick win, or silver bullet that can be implemented to protect institutions from similar failings.

Synergy is committed to continuing to be a leading voice on culture, governance, risk and performance.

“We are hosting the Chairman of AMP, David Murray, on the 8th of May at the Realm. David is leading figure in the financial industry he will provide valuable insights for the APS. David will be joined by Ray Griggs who brings his experience in leading the implementation of the Department of Defence’s response to Child Sexual Abuse Royal Commission, and Carmel McGregor who has deep experience in working on workforce, culture and reform in the APS. They will be joined by my colleague Paulette Robinson who works daily with APS agencies on governance, performance, and the PGPA Act. This event is a fantastic opportunity to explore the questions of culture, governance and risk in the APS,” says Toole.

To register for Synergy’s Culture, Governance and Risk event where David Murray, AO, Chairman of AMP, will share his insights and view moving forward, email events@synergygroup.net.au.

 

About the author

By Synergy Group

Founded in 1999, Synergy has grown to become one of Canberra’s leading professional services firms. We are government specialists delivering a truly collaborative approach to navigate important challenges and provide practical solutions.

People: David Schmitchen Sally Dorsett

Companies: AMP

Partners: Synergy Group

Tags: agency Australian Public Sector Governance Government leaders Performance and Accountability Act Public Governance Royal Commission

Login
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

The essential resource for effective
public sector professionals

Check out the Latest

By Synergy Group

Tuesday May 7, 2019
mm
Text size: A A A

Upcoming Events

30
Aug
HR Connect 2022 – Sydney
06
Sep
HR Connect 2022 – Auckland
06
Sep
Insights from the Government Regulatory Technology Survey
03
Aug
Playing Bigger: Uplevelling Influence + Impact for Public Sector Leaders – ONLINE PROGRAM
15
Aug
CILT International Diploma in Logistics and Transport (Public-Sector)
View Calendar

Partner Content

PSMP Inspires Harvard Study Opportunity

PSMP Inspires Harvard Study Opportunity

Whitepaper: Data security during a machinery of government change
Promoted

Whitepaper: Data security during a machinery of government change

Whitepaper: Data management during a machinery of government change
Promoted

Whitepaper: Data management during a machinery of government change

Latest Jobs


  • Chief Economist

    The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

    • National
    Closing date 4th September, 2022
    3 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Chief Strategy and Innovation Officer

    Department of Customer Service

    • NSW CBD, Regional
    Closing date 19th August, 2022
    8 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR | AUSTRALIAN-AMERICAN FULBRIGHT COMMISSION

    Australian-American Fulbright Commission

    • ACT CBD
    Closing date 29th August, 2022
    15 days ago Full Time - Fixed Term
  • Assistant Secretary, Communications

    Department of Education Skills and Employment

    • ACT
    Closing date 1st September, 2022
    2 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Trans-Tasman IP Attorneys Board - expressions of interest

    IP Australia

    • ACT
    Closing date 31st August, 2022
    3 days ago Contract/Project
  • General Manager, Capability

    Sports Integrity Australia

    • ACT
    Closing date 21st August, 2022
    11 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
Search All Jobs

Login

Get Premium now. Not ready? Get the free Daily newsletter.

Forgot password?

Share via email

Access your 3 free Mandarin Premium articles

As part of your free trial you will receive 'The Juice', The Mandarin's daily free newsletter, the 'Premium wrap' every Saturday and marketing emails. You can opt out at any time.
Content
  • News
  • Research Series
  • Features
  • Portfolios
  • Jurisdictions
  • New Zealand
  • People & Capability
  • Thought Leadership
  • Editors’ Picks
  • Resource Library
  • Site Map
Products & Services
  • The Juice Newsletter
  • Partner & Advertising solutions
  • Mandarin Live
  • Public Sector Events Calendar
  • Partner Content
  • Premium
  • Careers
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Usage
  • Code of Conduct
Connect
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Support
  • Our Team
Social
Copyright © The Mandarin
Private Media logo CRIKEY SMARTCOMPANY
wpDiscuz