Coronavirus Government Global Briefing: May 18

By Chris Woods

May 18, 2020

Welcome to Coronavirus Government Global Briefing, Mandarin Premium’s morning update on everything in local and global government responses to the COVID-19 outbreak.

England announces nursing home testing blitz

As the number of people who have died with COVID-19 in English and Welsh nursing homes exceeds 12,500 — at least one third of the UK’s death toll of 34,000 — The Guardian reports that the Johnson government has announced plans to test all staff and residents for the virus by early June.

In a press briefing on Friday, UK Health Secretary Matt Hancock defended the government’s early response by arguing that preventative measures had “protected 64% of care homes, almost two-thirds, of having any coronavirus cases at all”.

“Right from the start we’ve tried to throw a protective ring around our care homes,” Hancock said.

“We set out our first advice in February, and as the virus grew, we’ve strengthened it throughout.”

But as commentators have been quick to note, the Department of Health’s guidance on 28 February — still available at — provided some hygiene and social distancing recommendations but maintained that, “it remains very unlikely that people receiving care in a care home or the community will become infected.”

“No need to do anything differently in any care setting at present,” the UK health department told care homes.

Compare and contrast with early rhetoric from Australia’s health department, which, as The Sydney Morning Herald reported on 26 February, urged nursing homes to develop active “containment processes” on top of hygiene control.

As The New Statesman unpacked in the 24 April report, ‘How the UK’s care homes were abandoned to coronavirus‘, the UK’s advice remained consistent up until 13 March, the same day the country recorded its 798th case.

On top of a failure of messaging, the paper reports that care homes were strained by the UK government’s effort to discharge hospital patients into social care ahead of the first wave of cases, as well as a lack of historic financial support and early-COVID personal protective equipment amongst care workers.

In early May, Ian O’Neal, the son of UK care home nurse Suzanne Loverseed who died after contracting the virus, said that a lack of PPE “killed her”:

“At the end, she worked in a care home, with patients dying of this virus. She had no PPE but fearlessly she carried on. That’s what killed her. That is also just like her: fancying the rules of nature, or the odds, somehow didn’t apply to her. But they did. It seems somehow unsurprising, then, that she died as she lived: sacrificing herself for others.”

USA wrap

  • Vox has unpacked the Democrats’ proposed $3 trillion stimulus package, aka the HEROES Act, which passed the House on Friday but is expected to be knocked back by the Republican-controlled Senate.
    • As Politico reports, a bloc of progressive House Democrats, as well as Senator Bernie Sanders, has criticised the proposal for subsidising insurance agencies through emergency health insurance program COBRA, rather than funding health care directly through Medicare or Medicaid.
  • In a BuzzFeed exclusive, a Stanford whistleblower has alleged that a controversial John Ioannidis antibody study — which, while not peer-reviewed, made headlines in mid-April for suggesting the rate of infection was 85x higher than previously believed — both ignored scientists’ warning and failed to disclose important financial ties to JetBlue Airways founder and anti-lockdown proponent David Neeleman.
  • The Wisconsin State Journal reports that, in a 4-3 decision, the Wisconsin Supreme Court struck down the state’s stay-at-home order; while the decision was a win for the Republican Legislature against Democratic Governor Tony Evers, some counties, such as Dane County and Milwaukee, created de-facto regional shutdowns.
  • According to The Daily Beast, Donald Trump and his aides are pressuring the CDC to change their methodology in counting COVID-19 deaths so as to revise down their national toll; officials have defended the count and alleged that, if anything, the country is undercounting deaths.

On the home front: Australia, EU ramp up pressure for WHO investigation

Ahead of today’s World Health Assembly in Geneva, the European Union and Australia have amassed support from over 60 other countries for an independent inquiry into the original coronavirus outbreak.

As the ABC reports, the EU motion — which does not specifically mention China or Wuhan — calls on the WHO to work with the World Organisation for Animal Health to conduct “scientific and collaborative field missions” and “identify the zoonotic source of the virus and the route of introduction to the human population, including the possible role of intermediate hosts”.

Neither the US nor, unsurprisingly, China have as yet backed the motion, but it has received support from countries including Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Turkey, Russia, South Africa and the UK.

While Australia’s early call for an inquiry led to ongoing political fallout, EU’s spokeswoman for foreign affairs, Virginie Battu-Henriksson, said the organisation is focused on reaching consensus and “really getting together and finding a solution which is workable for all”.

“Of course, we need to have the support of all the major players, and China is one of them,” Battu-Henriksson told the ABC.

“For us, it is not the moment for us to enter any kind of blame game as we’ve seen in narratives from one part or another of the world.”

Reportedly, US diplomats have been pressing for tougher language that specifically calls for an inquiry into the Wuhan outbreak.

As the Trump administration continues to blame China in the face of a death toll in the tens of thousands, another European diplomatic source has told the ABC that, while he was “quite optimistic” the motion will succeed, the push for an inquiry could collapse if the United States and China use today’s meeting as an opportunity for another proxy war.

Victoria announces tentative roadmap for venues

Yesterday, the Victorian government announced that cafes, restaurants, pubs and other hospitality businesses can begin planning for a phased re-opening from the beginning of June.

Premier Dan Andrews emphasised that, “dependent on Victorians continuing to get tested when they show even mild symptoms and on those tests continuing to show low numbers of positive cases around the state,” venues will be able to reopen with staggered size limits:

  • From 1 June: Cafes, restaurants and pubs will be able to reopen their doors to serve meals to up to 20 customers at a time per enclosed space.
  • From 22 June: Up to 50 patrons.
  • During the second half of July: Up to 100.

Andrews also announced a number of now-standard precautions for venues, including physical distancing requirements of one person per four square metres, tables to be spaced at least 1.5 metres apart, and safety requirements such as extra cleaning, staff health screening and temperature checks.

One at least cursory difference between Victoria and other states will be the requirement for venues to take the contact details of every, presumably dine-in customer to assist in rapid contact tracing. Further work will also be done on managing shared areas such as entrances and bathrooms, and be conducted in consultation with industry, unions, and public health teams.

Prior to each of those dates, the Chief Health Officer will review transmission rates and testing, tracing and healthcare capacity.

“If, in the coming weeks, we see a sudden upswing in community exposures from an unknown source – we may have to make the call to delay,” Dan Andrews said.

“Similarly, if an initial opening led to a whole series of uncontrolled crowds or breaches –we’d look at that pretty seriously too.”

As the ABC reports, the announcement thus far excludes venues that only serve drinks, a decision that has elicited criticism from bar and pub owners concerned with Melbourne’s music-city status.

NSW pledges $20m in housing, legal support for international students

On Saturday, the ABC reported that Minister for Skills and Tertiary Education Geoff Lee announced a $20 million international students package to include a temporary housing scheme delivered through approved student accommodation or homestay providers.

The package also includes support for International Legal Service NSW and a new 24/7 international student support service that, via the NSW Government COVID-19 hotline, will offer advice on eviction moratoriums, and medical, mental health, legal and emergency support.

As SBS reports, the package clocks in at less than half of Victoria’s $45 million scheme, which includes cash payments of up to $1,100 for students who have lost work and are ineligible for JobKeeper/JobSeeker.

NSW was the final state to announce targeted support for international students; Premier Gladys Berejiklian had previously insisted the sector was a responsibility of the federal government’s.

State wrap

  • As the ABC reports, Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk has rebuffed calls from NSW ministers to reopen the state’s border.
  • Victoria will today announce a $2.7 billion “building blitz” package, which The Age reports will include $500 million directed at new and upgraded social housing. Over the weekend, the state government also announced:
  • According to The Sydney Morning Herald, the NSW government is planning pop-up car parks and bike lanes in Sydney’s CBD amongst a fear that eased restrictions will lead to overcrowding on public transport.
  • Ahead of the alternative Territory Day celebration, the NT government launched MusicNT’s listener poll ‘Territory Sounds Countdown‘, to open 1 June.
  • From today, measures in Tasmania will allow up to five visitors in households, gatherings of up to 10 people (not including event or premises staff) for indoor venues and outdoor gatherings.
  • ACT has announced a temporary driver licensing scheme to automatically extend any learner licences by 12 months if they were otherwise due to expire between 23 March 2020 and 1 January 2021.

Greens launch plan for jobs guarantee, free uni

Finally, in domestic politics, the Australian Greens will today launch ‘Invest To Recovery’, a plan to guarantee anyone under 30 a job, better income, or a free place at university or TAFE.

The party’s plan to rebuild the economy, which would require the federal government take on billions of debt, will call for:

  • almost 900,000 jobs building renewable energy infrastructure in the public and private sectors
  • $60 billion to revive domestic manufacturing and processing
  • a $2.3 billion entertainment and creative industries fund to put artists into every school and library in Australia and pay for festivals, films and live performances
  • maintaining the JobSeeker rate of $1,100 a fortnight

Last week, the party also signed on to a global call to forgive student debt in the face of the global recession.

While the federal Coalition has warned that increased government debt will have to be worn by future generations, Greens leader Adam Bandt has told the ABC that, “if we don’t offer every young person a job, a study place or a decent income, we risk creating a lost generation.”

“We learnt from the global financial crisis that for young people who are starting their working lives at a time of recession, they carry the scars with them for life unless they’re given the opportunity of good, decent work with decent security working on meaningful projects,” Bandt said.

“We owe this to young people because otherwise we’ll be stuck paying for income support for a very long time for what could be a lost generation.”

For health department updates: Federal, NSW, Victoria, QueenslandACTSouth AustraliaTasmaniaNorthern Territory and Western Australia.

About the author
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

The essential resource for effective
public sector professionals