• Free Daily Newsletter
  • Get Premium
  • Small Logo
  • About
  • Partner Pages
  • Support & FAQs
  • Log in

The Mandarin

The Mandarin
The Mandarin
  • Small Logo
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors' Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library
  • Small Logo
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors' Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library

Promoted

Home Sponsored Contract negotiation for the public sector – how to get a better outcome

Contract negotiation for the public sector – how to get a better outcome

By John Glenn

Wednesday May 5, 2021

shaking-hands
(Image: Adobe/ASDF)

If we saved just 1% on procurement, what could we do?

In 2017, the federal government executed $47bn of new contracts.¹

Negotiating a 1% reduction would have saved $470m, almost half a billion dollars.

One per cent. 

Looked at another way, that 1% could be ten new specialist cancer units in regional Australia, or fifty thousand university scholarships for students from low income households, or $250 for every aged pensioner. It’s a small change, with a serious impact.

Why doesn’t the public sector negotiate harder?

Often, people just don’t know how. Contract negotiation, particularly in the public sector, frequently falls to an officer or staff member who does it once or twice a year, if that. Contract ‘management’ focuses narrowly on contract administration, feeding the machine with standard activity data instead of critically assessing the way the engagement has developed over time and ensuring the contract keeps pace.

And sometimes, people just get complacent. I once worked with a senior public sector manager to prepare the scope and approach to market for a major outsourced services contract that was due to be renewed in the next few years. Contracts of this size take a long time to get to market, so the client had sensibly started early, and even more sensibly sought professional help at an early stage.

I suggested to this manager that the contact he managed was ripe for renegotiation right now, for the two or three years it had left to run. I was confident that it could be significantly improved – so confident I was willing to stake my fee on it and do the renegotiation for a percentage of what I saved the organisation. He said, “It’s not worth it for $4m.”

It was worth it, someone has to care.

How can the public sector do better?

Here are three key things to understand when negotiating on behalf of the public sector:

1. The public-private boundary is a cross-cultural negotiation

The value conversation between business to business is simple. The nuances may be different, but the big picture is the same – impact on the bottom line.

Value in the public sector is a different beast. It’s a social good, a capability, a political imperative.

There are few hard measures, and there are always budget constraints. There’s a different language and a different currency. The public sector has influences, objectives and controls that don’t exist in the private sector. It’s a cross-cultural negotiation in an environment of public scrutiny with policy, regulatory and behavioural constraints.

Yet often industry fails to recognise this. And the public sector often fails to recognise or understand the commercial imperatives of their suppliers. This mismatch of values leads to a consequent mismatch of expectations and behaviours, which leads to damaged relationships and stress on the contracted services. Things can fall into disarray, and from there rapidly into dispute.

Building public-private sector agreement needs a different approach than business-to-business and a broader view than achieved with only a public service background. We know this because we have been building these agreements for more than 20 years.

2. Understand the other party’s interests as well as your own

We are often told that in negotiations, we should seek an outcome that is ‘win-win’. I have never had a client say to me, ‘Now John, I want you to be sure that the other side gets to win too. I prefer to talk about ‘enlightened self-interest’. In simple terms, that’s where I help you get what you want, so that you’ll help me get what I want.

It’s not win-win, it’s about unlocking value.

Things that matter to me will matter less to you, and vice versa. We can find ways to share that value. And by the way, nothing says I have to share it 50/50. As long as you are satisfied with the deal, enough that we can have a good relationship going forward into the contract, we’re all happy.

In mediation, we say that, ‘When I understand your perspective, my perspective changes forever.’ I don’t have to agree with you, but I do need to understand you.

I’ve led a negotiation where the preferred vendor was almost eliminated because their tendered price was almost a million dollars more than the nearest competitor. I convinced the client to undertake parallel negotiations with both vendors. This meant we could ask questions and look under the surface. Sure enough, part of the request for tender was ambiguous. Each vendor had answered the requirement as best they could, but each had interpreted it differently. When we clarified the requirement and could compare apples with apples, the price difference went away.

The private sector often fails to recognise public sector interests. It is not money. Equally though, it is simplistic for the public sector to think the private sector interest is price.

3. Don’t expect your people to be able to negotiate effectively without training and practice

Negotiation is like tennis. Most of us play occasionally, usually a hit-and-giggle match. Some of us have a natural talent. A very few can be a Wimbledon champion. Even the best of us improve, faster, with coaching and practice.

The challenge is that most training is designed around business-to-business agreements, delivered by business people. It is not enough.

Look for training and support that understands you, in your context, in your environment, with your risk profile, behaviours and expectations, and with your constraints.

It does need something different if you want a different outcome.

Think differently, be different

I recently negotiated a 30% reduction on a five-year contract of $100m pa. Sadly, it wasn’t hard because the deal was built poorly. Traditionally, with traditional help.  

A 1% improvement on a contract of reasonable size and complexity is the minimum you should be aiming for. It adds up to scholarships, pensions and hospitals.  Without even thinking that broadly, it is more for you to do more in your role. 

Without a doubt, the better your negotiation skills, the better your outcomes. 

Thinking differently means different outcomes.  

Can you think differently enough to save 1, 5, or 10%? What will you do with the money you’ve saved? 

What have you got to lose but 30 minutes of your time? Try something different – contact us! 

www.kiah.com


¹Source: ANAO Australian Government Procurement Contract Reporting

About the author
John Glenn

By John Glenn

John Glenn is founder and managing director of Kiah Consulting.

People: John Glenn

Departments: Federal Government

Partners: Kiah Consulting

Tags: agreements budget case study complex negotiations contract negotiation John Glenn Kiah Consulting Management management consultancy negotiation partnerships private sector Procurement Public Sector public service public-private partnerships service contracts tendering

Login
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
The Mandarin Premium

Canberra’s changed

Stay on top for only $5 a week

 

Get Premium Today

Already a subscriber? Login

By John Glenn

Wednesday May 5, 2021
John Glenn
Text size: A A A

Upcoming Events

01
Apr
Postgraduate studies in regulation and governance at ANU RegNet
14
Jul
Building Visibility + Influence for Women in the Public Sector – MASTERCLASS
03
Aug
Playing Bigger: Uplevelling Influence + Impact for Public Sector Leaders – ONLINE PROGRAM
15
Aug
CILT International Diploma in Logistics and Transport (Public-Sector)
21
Jun
Humanify HR Consulting – HR Leadership in Practice (HRLP)
View Calendar

Partner Content

Data-centric, not data centres: the future of digital citizen services
Promoted

Data-centric, not data centres: the future of digital citizen services

In Victoria, providing for the safety of children requires integrated, agile systems
Promoted

In Victoria, providing for the safety of children requires integrated, agile systems

eBook: Digitisation and Modernisation in Public Health Organizations

eBook: Digitisation and Modernisation in Public Health Organizations

Latest Jobs


  • Head of Programs

    Cranlana Centre for Ethical Leadership at Monash University

    • VIC CBD
    Closing date 22nd July, 2022
    4 days ago Full Time - Fixed Term
  • General Manager Decision Support Services

    Bureau of Meteorology

    • National
    Closing date 10th July, 2022
    6 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Multiple Directors - Engagement, Partnerships and Communications

    Department of Customer Service

    • NSW CBD, Regional
    Closing date 1st June, 2022
    1 month ago Full Time - Fixed Term
  • Executive Director Corporate Services - Canberra, Melbourne or Sydney

    Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity

    • VIC CBD
    Closing date 3rd July, 2022
    7 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Executive Director Corporate Services - Canberra, Melbourne or Sydney

    Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity

    • ACT CBD, Regional
    Closing date 3rd July, 2022
    7 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Executive Director Corporate Services - Canberra, Melbourne or Sydney

    Australian Commission for Law Enforcement Integrity

    • NSW
    Closing date 3rd July, 2022
    7 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
Search All Jobs

Login

Get Premium now. Not ready? Get the free Daily newsletter.

Forgot password?

Share via email

Access your 3 free Mandarin Premium articles

As part of your free trial you will receive 'The Juice', The Mandarin's daily free newsletter, the 'Premium wrap' every Saturday and marketing emails. You can opt out at any time.
Content
  • Small Logo
  • News
  • Research Series
  • Features
  • Portfolios
  • Jurisdictions
  • New Zealand
  • People & Capability
  • Thought Leadership
  • Editors' Picks
  • Resource Library
  • Site Map
Products & Services
  • Small Logo
  • The Juice Newsletter
  • Partner & Advertising solutions
  • Mandarin Live
  • Public Sector Events Calendar
  • Partner Content
  • Premium
  • Careers
Legal
  • Small Logo
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Usage
  • Code of Conduct
Connect
  • Small Logo
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Support
  • Our Team
Social
Copyright © The Mandarin
Private Media logo CRIKEY SMARTCOMPANY
wpDiscuz