• Free Daily Newsletter
  • Get Premium
  • Small Logo
  • About
  • Partner Pages
  • Support & FAQs
  • Log in

The Mandarin

The Mandarin
The Mandarin
  • Small Logo
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors' Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library
  • Small Logo
  • Premium
  • Careers
    • Search SES Jobs
    • Career Advice
  • News
  • Editors' Picks
  • Portfolios
  • Events
  • Resource library

Home Features If we want an ideas boom we must shift the regulatory mindset

If we want an ideas boom we must shift the regulatory mindset

By The Mandarin

Friday February 19, 2016

The ride-sharing service Uber is challenging regulators across the country. It’s a perfect example of how new innovative business models are transforming the regulatory challenge.

Chris Noone, CEO of publicly listed Collaborate Corporation, has experienced frustration with the existing regulatory frameworks in operating the organisation’s multiple sharing economy businesses, including DriveMyCar.

“Because these regulations have not been created with the sharing economy in mind, if you ask the one question of a department five times, you are likely to get five different answers,” he said.

“There’s no consistency in the interpretation of regulations. And that’s totally understandable because they were created before the sharing economy had taken off and it’s probably the first time the people who are answering these questions have come across this.”

Principal consultant at Nous Group, Claire Noone, says this type of frustration can hamper innovators. She says now is the time to start creating regulatory frameworks that encourage and foster innovation and accommodate new business models.

“We could stymie our innovation potential by not thinking through … new regulatory models.”

“In the innovation conversation we are talking about new products, new services, new business models and entrepreneurship, but we’re not talking about new ideas and approaches to regulation,” she said.

“In the context of the innovation statement, if we don’t start to think about the role of regulation in innovation, we risk missing a huge opportunity. We could stymie our innovation potential by not thinking through and implementing new regulatory models.”

Noone says two key shifts need to take place for regulatory frameworks to support innovation. The first is to create more flexible and outcomes-based regulatory frameworks.

“We need to design regulation that can respond quickly to technological change,” she said. “For example, five years ago we wouldn’t have anticipated that people would be banking on their mobile phones, sharing their homes through Airbnb, sharing rides on Uber, or renting their cars through DriveMyCar. Regulation needs to anticipate the future, be nimble and able to respond quickly when we do things differently.”

Environmental regulation offers a successful example of regulating with a flexible risk and outcomes-based approach. “Environmental policy and regulation has moved from command and control regulation to setting out what companies must do to provide environmental outcomes,” Noone said.

“Because specific solutions to problems are not stipulated by the regulation, the way a business achieves outcomes is up to them. Businesses are often trying to achieve the most efficient and effective outcomes, which is enabled by more flexible legislative frameworks.”

Why existing processes don’t work

The existing policy and legislation making processes pose a challenge to innovative business models.

“It takes a long time to change the legislative framework. So being flexible means we also need to identify where the policy process can be made faster, and how to do that,” Noone explained. “The way we currently develop legislation is not fast enough to respond to the changing nature of the economy.”

“I am advocating that we turn the discussion around to encourage a new mindset …”

The second and most important shift is about mindset. Facilitating innovation is key; Noone says we need to change the way we think about regulatory reform.

“We’ve had a lot of what I would call removing obstacles or reducing red tape discussions, but I am advocating that we turn the discussion around to encourage a new mindset that is about enabling innovation, rather than simply removing obstacles. This requires us to think differently about the regulatory framework and the practice of regulators,” she said.

Given it takes a long time to change the legislative framework, regulators must think about how they adapt their approach to the new business environment, focusing on risk and impact rather than on black letter law.

Regulators — whether they be telecommunications, financial market, taxi or consumer regulators — need to adopt a mindset that enables rather than stymies innovation.

“If we’re saying the ideas boom is the new mining boom, then how we make and implement regulation that not only removes obstacles but also positively enables innovation is a challenge we must overcome,” Noone said.

About the author
The Mandarin

By The Mandarin

The Mandarin staff journalists.

Companies: Airbnb Collaborate Corporation Nous Group Uber

Partners: Nous Group

Tags: Airbnb Collaborate Corporation digital government e-government Nous Group regulation Regulatory policy sharing economy taxi regulation Uber

Login
Please login to comment
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
brucemuirhead
brucemuirhead
4 years ago

Great article. A couple of thoughts in response. I think the further upstream our regulators are in the idea design, development and implementation process – the more successful we will be in aligning our collective needs. Also, we need to continue to see a liberal and open approach to regulating the disruptive and avoid a mass outbreak of costly and duplicitous trial and error across various jurisdictions. Our experience with Uber, Taxi and Limousine Review encouraged us in the way government was open to new methodologies: https://mindhive.org/slp/opt_blog.html

0
The Mandarin Premium

Insights for policy professionals.

Subscribe for only $5 a week.

Get Premium Today

Already a subscriber? Login

By The Mandarin

Friday February 19, 2016
The Mandarin
Text size: A A A

Upcoming Events

28
Jan
[Roundtable] Government Data Security and Office 365
11
Feb
Reverse and Reciprocal Mentoring Webinar
15
Feb
Applying Behavioural Science to Create Change
16
Feb
Innovation Reset 2020: Trust | Empathy | Competence – How the new public work is the new work of government, the public service and many others too.
17
Feb
Proud Partnerships in Place: 2021 First Peoples Public Administration Virtual Conference
View Calendar

Partner Content

Whitepaper: Leveraging government data in a multi-cloud world

Whitepaper: Leveraging government data in a multi-cloud world

So what did we learn from 2020? Quite a lot: here’s how to make fast progress stick
Promoted

So what did we learn from 2020? Quite a lot: here’s how to make fast progress stick

eBook: Building digital trust in the post COVID-19 world

eBook: Building digital trust in the post COVID-19 world

Latest Jobs


  • Management Consultant

    Kiah Consulting

    • ACT
    Closing date 28th January, 2021
    7 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • Chief Information Officer, Transport Canberra and City Services

    Transport Canberra and City Service

    • ACT
    Closing date 27th January, 2021
    12 days ago Full Time - Fixed Term
  • Director Community Construction and Development

    The Department of Communities

    • WA
    Closing date 25th January, 2021
    12 days ago Full Time - Fixed Term
  • CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER

    Australian Institute of Health and Welfare

    • ACT
    Closing date 27th January, 2021
    1 month ago
  • General Manager, Electricity Markets Branch

    Department of Industry, Science, Energy & Resources

    • ACT CBD
    Closing date 14th February, 2021
    2 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
  • 3x Manager Roles (Assessments, Investigations and Resolutions)

    Health Care Complaints Commission

    • NSW CBD
    Closing date 3rd February, 2021
    5 days ago Full Time - Ongoing
Search All Jobs

Login

New to The Mandarin? Create an account

Forgot password?

Share via email

Access your 3 free Mandarin Premium articles

As part of your free trial you will receive 'The Juice', The Mandarin's daily free newsletter, the 'Premium wrap' every Saturday and marketing emails. You can opt out at any time.
Content
  • Small Logo
  • News
  • Research Series
  • Features
  • Portfolios
  • Jurisdictions
  • New Zealand
  • People & Capability
  • Thought Leadership
  • Editors' Picks
  • Resource Library
  • Site Map
Products & Services
  • Small Logo
  • The Juice Newsletter
  • Partner & Advertising solutions
  • Mandarin Live
  • Public Sector Events Calendar
  • Partner Content
  • Premium
  • Careers
Legal
  • Small Logo
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Usage
  • Code of Conduct
Connect
  • Small Logo
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Support
  • Our Team
Social
Copyright © The Mandarin
Private Media logo CRIKEY SMARTCOMPANY STARTUPSMART
wpDiscuz